By type and community
Independent & Secular Schools in Fishers, Noblesville & Cicero
9 independent & secular schools in Fishers, Noblesville & Cicero; 1 are on the 2026-27 Choice list. Eastern Hamilton County from Geist to Morse Reservoir, including the area's largest Islamic school and two Adventist campuses near Cicero.
Where this comes from. School facts are from the NCES Private School Survey (2023-24, or 2021-22 where a school did not respond) and, for schools missing from it, from state lists. Choice status is IDOE's 2026-27 participating list as downloaded October 28, 2026; SGO status is IDOE's partner list dated October 21, 2026; ESA status is IDOE's August 31, 2026 provider sheet. Indiana does not publish private tuition; confirm it with the school.
Funding note: Independent schools that charge more than the voucher typically fill the gap with need-based aid; a few large ones partner with SGOs instead of joining Choice.
| School | Type | Community | Grades | Choice 2026-27 | SGO / ESA | Choice students 2025-26 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Acton Academy Fishers 8865 S St, Fishers 46038 | Independent & Secular Schools | Fishers, Noblesville & Cicero | Not reported | Not listed | — | — |
| Community Montessori School 9069 E 141st St, Fishers 46038 | Independent & Secular Schools | Fishers, Noblesville & Cicero | PK-6 | Not listed | — | — |
| Faith Montessori PO Box 991, Noblesville 46060 | Independent & Secular Schools | Fishers, Noblesville & Cicero | Not reported | Not listed | — · ESA | — |
| Leafspring School at Geist 10408 Olio Rd, Fishers 46040 | Independent & Secular Schools | Fishers, Noblesville & Cicero | PK-K | Not listed | — | — |
| Premier Soccer Academy 9741 East 153th Street, Noblesville 46060 | Independent & Secular Schools | Fishers, Noblesville & Cicero | 4-10 | ✓ In Person | SGO | — |
| Primrose School at Bridgewater 14711 N Gray Rd, Westfield 46062 | Independent & Secular Schools | Fishers, Noblesville & Cicero | PK-K | Not listed | — | — |
| Primrose School at Gray Eagle 12290 Olio Rd, Fishers 46037 | Independent & Secular Schools | Fishers, Noblesville & Cicero | PK-K | Not listed | — | — |
| Primrose School of Noblesville 15707 N Pointe Blvd, Noblesville 46060 | Independent & Secular Schools | Fishers, Noblesville & Cicero | PK-K | Not listed | — | — |
| Primrose School of West Fishers 12609 Parkside Dr, Fishers 46038 | Independent & Secular Schools | Fishers, Noblesville & Cicero | PK | Not listed | — | — |
Every school in Fishers, Noblesville & Cicero All independent & secular schools
See which Indiana programs fit your child
Five questions, about two minutes. Then a tuition counselor phones with your district's voucher figure and the layers that stack on it.