By community
Private and church schools in Fishers, Noblesville & Cicero
Eastern Hamilton County from Geist to Morse Reservoir, including the area's largest Islamic school and two Adventist campuses near Cicero. We track 19 private schools here; 10 are on the 2026-27 Choice list.
Where this comes from. School facts are from the NCES Private School Survey (2023-24, or 2021-22 where a school did not respond) and, for schools missing from it, from state lists. Choice status is IDOE's 2026-27 participating list as downloaded October 28, 2026; SGO status is IDOE's partner list dated October 21, 2026; ESA status is IDOE's August 31, 2026 provider sheet. Indiana does not publish private tuition; confirm it with the school.
19
Private schools in our file10
On the 2026-27 Choice list9
SGO partner schools (Oct 2026)6
Approved ESA school providers11
Start at pre-K (federal survey)1,840
Choice students enrolled in 2025-26 (IDOE report)By type
Independent & Secular Schools
9 in Fishers
Browse →Christian Schools
6 in Fishers
Browse →Catholic Schools
3 in Fishers
Browse →Islamic, Jewish, Orthodox & Other Faith Schools
1 in Fishers
Browse →All 19 schools in Fishers, Noblesville & Cicero
| School | Type | Community | Grades | Choice 2026-27 | SGO / ESA | Choice students 2025-26 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Acton Academy Fishers 8865 S St, Fishers 46038 | Independent & Secular Schools | Fishers, Noblesville & Cicero | Not reported | Not listed | — | — |
| Cicero SDA Elementary 24089 State Road 19, Cicero 46034 | Christian Schools | Fishers, Noblesville & Cicero | 1-8 | ✓ In Person | SGO | 34 |
| Community Montessori School 9069 E 141st St, Fishers 46038 | Independent & Secular Schools | Fishers, Noblesville & Cicero | PK-6 | Not listed | — | — |
| Eman Schools 11965 Allisonville Rd, Fishers 46038 | Islamic, Jewish, Orthodox & Other Faith Schools | Fishers, Noblesville & Cicero | PK-12 | ✓ In Person | SGO · ESA | 425 |
| Faith Montessori PO Box 991, Noblesville 46060 | Independent & Secular Schools | Fishers, Noblesville & Cicero | Not reported | Not listed | — · ESA | — |
| Fishers Christian Academy 9587 E 131st St, Fishers 46038 | Christian Schools | Fishers, Noblesville & Cicero | PK-12 | ✓ Hybrid | SGO · ESA | 106 |
| Indiana Academy 24815 State Road 19, Cicero 46034 | Christian Schools | Fishers, Noblesville & Cicero | 9-12 | ✓ In Person | SGO · ESA | 95 |
| Leafspring School at Geist 10408 Olio Rd, Fishers 46040 | Independent & Secular Schools | Fishers, Noblesville & Cicero | PK-K | Not listed | — | — |
| Legacy Christian School 470 Lakeview Dr, Noblesville 46060 | Christian Schools | Fishers, Noblesville & Cicero | PK-12 | ✓ In Person | SGO · ESA | 198 |
| Mission Christian Academy 13095 Publisher’s Drive, Fishers 46038 | Christian Schools | Fishers, Noblesville & Cicero | K-12 | ✓ In Person | — · ESA | — |
| Noah's Ark Preschool & Kindergarten 10500 E 126th St, Fishers 46038 | Christian Schools | Fishers, Noblesville & Cicero | PK-K | Not listed | — | — |
| Our Lady of Grace School 9900 E 191st St, Noblesville 46060 | Catholic Schools | Fishers, Noblesville & Cicero | K-8 | ✓ In Person | SGO | 341 |
| Premier Soccer Academy 9741 East 153th Street, Noblesville 46060 | Independent & Secular Schools | Fishers, Noblesville & Cicero | 4-10 | ✓ In Person | SGO | — |
| Primrose School at Bridgewater 14711 N Gray Rd, Westfield 46062 | Independent & Secular Schools | Fishers, Noblesville & Cicero | PK-K | Not listed | — | — |
| Primrose School at Gray Eagle 12290 Olio Rd, Fishers 46037 | Independent & Secular Schools | Fishers, Noblesville & Cicero | PK-K | Not listed | — | — |
| Primrose School of Noblesville 15707 N Pointe Blvd, Noblesville 46060 | Independent & Secular Schools | Fishers, Noblesville & Cicero | PK-K | Not listed | — | — |
| Primrose School of West Fishers 12609 Parkside Dr, Fishers 46038 | Independent & Secular Schools | Fishers, Noblesville & Cicero | PK | Not listed | — | — |
| St. Louis de Montfort Catholic School 11421 Hague Rd, Fishers 46038 | Catholic Schools | Fishers, Noblesville & Cicero | PK-8 | ✓ In Person | SGO | 297 |
| St. Theodore Guerin High School 15300 N Gray Rd, Noblesville 46062 | Catholic Schools | Fishers, Noblesville & Cicero | 9-12 | ✓ In Person | SGO | 344 |
ZIP codes: 46037, 46038, 46040, 46060, 46062, 46034
Find funding for a school in Fishers
Five questions, about two minutes. Then a tuition counselor phones with your district's voucher figure and the layers that stack on it.